As of March 9, 2025, Amazon sellers find themselves at a crossroads, wrestling with an appeal process that has undergone subtle yet impactful changes throughout 2024 and into early 2025. Drawing from discussions across seller forums like Amazon Seller Central, posts on X, and expert analysis from AMZ Sellers Attorney®, this article unpacks the evolving landscape, offering actionable insights for sellers facing account suspensions, listing deactivations, or policy disputes.
The State of Appeals in 2024: A Frustrating Baseline
In 2024, seller forums were abuzz with grievances about Amazon’s appeal process, often likened to a “black box” where submissions disappeared into a void of generic responses. A Seller Central thread from November 18, 2024, exemplifies this: a seller detailed a three-step cycle—submitting an appeal, receiving a rejection citing already-provided information, and hitting a wall with Account Health representatives who offered little beyond scripted replies. This wasn’t an isolated case; sellers frequently reported submitting multiple Plans of Action (POAs) only to face silence or outright denials without clear reasoning.
The frustration stemmed from Amazon’s apparent reliance on automated systems, which sellers speculated were prioritizing efficiency over fairness. For instance, intellectual property complaints—often lodged by competitors—could trigger instant deactivations, leaving sellers scrambling to appeal with little guidance. Forum users lamented the lack of a two-way dialogue, wishing for a system where they could respond directly to Amazon’s feedback rather than resubmitting blindly.
Policy Shifts in 2024 and Their Ripple Effects
A pivotal change in 2024 was Amazon’s insistence on supply chain documentation in addition to invoices, requiring sellers to submit product documentation to avoid listing or suspension issues. This, in conjunction with Amazon's In Person Video process (IPI) resulted in many seller accounts being deactivated for "fraudulent or illegal activity" but the real rub was the lack of supply chain documents, which many legitimate suppliers are reluctant to provide.
Additionally, Amazon tightened its enforcement of account health metrics in 2024, with sellers reporting more frequent suspensions for minor infractions, such as late shipment rates or customer complaints. This heightened scrutiny meant appeals became a more common necessity, yet the appeal process remained stubbornly slow to adapt, leaving sellers caught between stricter rules and an unchanged reinstatement system.
Early 2025: Signs of Evolution or More of the Same?
By early 2025, seller forums hinted at incremental changes, though concrete evidence of a major overhaul remained elusive. Some sellers on X speculated about faster review times—down from weeks to days in certain cases—possibly driven by competitive pressures or vocal seller advocacy. Others noted slightly more detailed rejection notices, suggesting Amazon might be tweaking its AI responses to offer a tad more clarity. However, the overarching sentiment was one of cautious skepticism; many felt these adjustments were superficial, with the core issues of transparency and human oversight still unresolved.
For example, a hypothetical X post from January 2025 might read: “Finally got a response on my appeal after 3 tries—Amazon pointed to a specific invoice issue this time. Progress? Maybe, but still no way to argue back.” Such anecdotes suggest a process in flux, nudged forward by seller pressure but far from a seller-friendly system. Here at AMZ Sellers Attorney® we have had many frustrated clients who complain of getting "template responses" within minutes of submission, suggesting their appeals are not even being read by a human being.
Seller Strategies and Workarounds
Amid these challenges, sellers shared creative workarounds in forums. Escalating appeals to higher levels within Amazon—sometimes by emailing executive contacts yielded occasional successes, though results were inconsistent. Others turned to third-party tools or services to track policy updates, ensuring their appeals aligned with the latest requirements. The disconnect between Amazon’s polished narrative of a “streamlined” process (touted since 2018 updates) and seller realities fueled a thriving ecosystem of consultants and attorneys specializing in reinstatement.
Tips for Navigating the New Appeal Process
1. Don’t Use Old Templates: The appeal process has evolved significantly since 2023, and using outdated templates from years past is a recipe for rejection in 2025. Amazon’s algorithms now expect POAs tailored to specific violations and current policies. For instance, a 2025 appeal for a counterfeit claim might need detailed supplier invoices and letters of authorization—generic “we’ll do better” submissions won’t suffice.
2. Don’t Apologize When It’s Amazon’s Mistake: If Amazon’s error caused the issue—like a system glitch wrongly flagging your account—avoid admitting fault or taking responsibility. Instead, present hard evidence (e.g., order logs, policy compliance proof) and firmly request correction. Over-apologizing can signal culpability, weakening your position when Amazon should be fixing its own mistake.
3. Consult Experts: With policies shifting fast, experts like AMZ Sellers Attorney® offer a lifeline. They track 2025’s latest appeal trends—such as which violation types Amazon prioritizes or how escalation tactics are evolving—giving you an edge over DIY attempts. Their success stories, like reinstating accounts in days, underscore the value of specialized knowledge.
The Bigger Picture: Amazon vs. Sellers
Critically, the gap between Amazon’s narrative and seller experiences reveals a deeper tension. Amazon positions its appeal process as efficient and fair, citing post-2018 improvements like reduced wait times. Yet, sellers in 2024-2025 argue it’s built to protect Amazon’s bottom line—prioritizing customer trust and platform integrity over seller equity. This asymmetry leaves smaller businesses particularly vulnerable, often lacking the resources to fight prolonged battles.
Looking ahead, the pressure from forums and third-party advocates might force more substantive changes by mid-2025—perhaps a dedicated appeal support team or clearer escalation paths. For now, though, sellers must play the game on Amazon’s terms, armed with vigilance and expert support.
Get Ahead with Expert Help
Navigating this shifting terrain solo is daunting, but you don’t have to. Watch this expert breakdown from AMZ Sellers Attorney® for deeper insights, and take the first step toward reinstatement today:
RSS Feed
