Illegal DMCA takedown requests on online platforms

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) is a United States copyright law that provides protection for copyright holders against copyright infringement. The DMCA also established a "notice-and-takedown" system, which allows copyright holders to notify online service providers (OSPs) of infringing content hosted on their platforms. OSPs are then required to remove the infringing content or disable access to it.
While the DMCA has been effective in reducing copyright infringement online, it has also been abused by some copyright holders and their agents to have legitimate content removed from online platforms. This is known as an illegal DMCA takedown request.

Illegal DMCA takedown requests can be motivated by a variety of factors, such as:

• Censorship: Copyright holders may use DMCA takedown requests to censor content that they find objectionable, even if the content is not actually infringing on their copyright.
• Competition: Copyright holders may use DMCA takedown requests to suppress competition from other businesses. For example, a software company may send DMCA takedown requests to websites that host pirated copies of its software, even if the websites also host legitimate content.
• Extortion: Copyright holders may use DMCA takedown requests to extort money from website owners. For example, a copyright holder may send a DMCA takedown request to a website owner, threatening to keep the website's content offline unless the owner pays a fee.

Illegal DMCA takedown requests can have a number of negative consequences, including:

• Chilling effect on free speech: Illegal DMCA takedown requests can create a chilling effect on free speech, as website owners may be reluctant to host content that could be targeted by a copyright holder, even if the content is legitimate.
• Harm to legitimate businesses: Illegal DMCA takedown requests can harm legitimate businesses that rely on online platforms to distribute their content. For example, a website that hosts user-generated content may be forced to remove legitimate content if it receives a DMCA takedown request from a copyright holder.
• Increased costs for online platforms: Online platforms must invest significant resources to process and respond to DMCA takedown requests. This can increase the cost of operating these platforms and make it more difficult for new platforms to enter the market.

Shopify's Lawsuit

In October 2023, Shopify filed a lawsuit against an unknown defendant for sending numerous false DMCA takedown requests. The takedown notices targeted listings on a variety of shops selling perfume products, claiming that they infringe copyright.
​
Shopify claims that the takedown notices were not legitimate and were instead being used to harass the company and its merchants. Shopify is seeking damages from the defendant and an injunction to prevent them from sending any further false DMCA takedown requests.

Conclusion

​Shopify's lawsuit highlights the growing problem of illegal DMCA takedown requests on online platforms. These requests can have a devastating impact on legitimate businesses and can create a chilling effect on free speech.

It is important to be aware of this problem and to take steps to combat it. If you receive a DMCA takedown request, you should carefully review the request to determine whether it is legitimate. If you believe that the request is illegitimate, you can file a counter-notice with the online platform. You may also want to consider consulting with an attorney to discuss your options.  AMZ Sellers Attorney® is always available for a free consultation, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.