AMAZON SELLERS ATTORNEY
  • Submit a case
  • Amazon Sellers Lawyer Services
    • Amazon Appeals| Reinstate Your Deactivated or Suspended Account >
      • Amazon Seller Appeal for Inauthentic Items
      • Amazon Appeal ODR Suspensions
      • Amazon Related Account Suspension Appeals
      • Appeal Amazon Verification Suspension
      • Amazon Restricted Product Appeals
      • KDP and ACX Termination Appeals
      • Amazon Drop Shipping Policy and Seller Code of Conduct Appeals
      • FBA Reimbursement and Reimbursement Abuse Suspensions| Appeals
      • Amazon Safety Complaints: How to Handle and Appeal Them
      • Sales Velocity Suspensions on Amazon: Appeal Strategies
      • Win Amazon Sales Rank Manipulation Suspension Appeals | Appeal Package
      • Win Price Gouging/Fair Pricing Suspensions Appeals - Get Reinstated Now
      • Amazon Review Manipulation Suspension Appeals
      • Amazon Variation Listing Policy Violation - Get Help with Our Appeal Package
      • Forged or Manipulated Documentation Suspensions: How to Appeal
      • Amazon Listing (ASIN) Removal? Reinstate Listing with Amazon Sellers Attorney
      • Amazon Seller Fraud or Illegal Activity: Suspension Appeals
      • Merch by Amazon Termination Appeals
      • Walmart Suspension Appeal
      • Ebay Suspension Appeals
      • Twitter Account Suspensions and Reinstatement
      • Amazon Account Hacked? Get Help with Account Suspension Appeals Today
      • How to Open a Second Amazon Seller Account
    • Trademark Registration and Amazon Brand Registry Support
    • How to Settle TRO Claims and Release Amazon Funds
    • Amazon Arbitration for Seller Funds: How to Sue Amazon and Win
    • Amazon Intellectual Property Infringement Complaints - Trademark, Patent, and Copyright Infringement
    • Appeal Closed or Limited PayPal Account
    • Protect Your Amazon Listing -- Hijacker Removal Service
    • DMCA Safe Harbor and Takedown Notices: Protect Your Copyrights
    • Defending Buyer Complaints
  • About
  • Amazon Sellers Lawyer Reviews
  • Amazon Sellers Blog---Latest News for Amazon Sellers
  • Amazon Suspension Prevention Service with Free Appeals
  • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Refund Policy

Amazon Sellers Blog: Latest News Affecting Amazon Sellers

Update on Amazon's Limitation of Liability

5/12/2023

 
Picture
Amazon's Business Solutions Agreement Section 8 limits the liability of Amazon to sellers to up to the equivalent of six months payments the seller has made to Amazon before account deactivation.  This is a clause that Amazon has been waving around in arbitration for years.  Unfortunately, because of Amazon's forced arbitration clause, not many case precedents are set because arbitrations are private.  However, a bankruptcy court in 2022 struck a mighty blow to this clause.  While not binding authority, since the Shaffer court was a federal court sitting in Arizona and not a Washington State court, the case provides persuasive authority to argue against the application of Amazon's precious liability clause.  This article will delve into the case and its implications, particularly on future arbitrations against Amazon.

Background: Shaffer v. Amazon Services LLC

The Shaffer v. Amazon Services LLC case involved Potential Dynamix LLC, an Amazon seller that filed for bankruptcy after Amazon terminated their selling privileges. The dispute centered around a clause in the Amazon Services Business Solutions Agreement that limited Amazon's liability. Amazon argued that damages should be capped based on this clause, but the bankruptcy court in Arizona disagreed. It ruled that the clause violated public policy and was unreasonable, a decision that has potential implications for future arbitration cases involving Amazon.

Implications for Arbitration Cases

1. Challenge to Amazon's Liability Limitation Clause
One key outcome of the Shaffer v. Amazon case is the challenge it presents to the enforceability of Amazon's liability limitation clause. This clause, found in the Amazon Services Business Solutions Agreement, typically caps Amazon's liability to the fees paid by the seller to Amazon in the preceding six months. However, the court's ruling suggests that this clause may be violative of public policy and could be deemed unreasonable in certain situations.

2. Focus on Fairness

The Shaffer v. Amazon case also underscores the importance of fairness in agreements between Amazon and its sellers. The court considered the Agreement a contract of adhesion, meaning it was offered on a "take it or leave it" basis, leaving the seller with little room to negotiate terms. This perceived imbalance in bargaining power could influence future arbitration proceedings, potentially leading arbitrators to scrutinize the fairness of Amazon's standard contracts more closely.  

At Amazon Sellers Attorney, we have successfully argued in arbitrations that section 2 of Amazon's Business Solutions Agreement, which allows Amazon to permanently withhold a seller's funds if the seller is suspected of using the account to commit fraud, illegal activity or a repeated violation of Amazon policy as unconscionable and unenforceable.  However, every arbitration has a different arbitrator, who may not be as well-versed in the law and may make an erroneous ruling.

3. Potential Increase in Claims

The court's refusal to enforce Amazon's liability limitation clause could potentially lead to an increase in the number and size of claims brought against Amazon. If sellers believe that they have a better chance of recovering larger damages, they may be more likely to initiate arbitration proceedings.

​4. Shift in Legal Strategies

The ruling may also prompt a shift in legal strategies. Amazon sellers and their legal teams may start to challenge the applicability of certain clauses in the Amazon Services Business Solutions Agreement, particularly those that seem to favor Amazon disproportionately.

Key Takeaways

The Shaffer v. Amazon Services LLC case represents a significant development in the legal landscape for Amazon sellers. It highlights the potential for challenging certain aspects of the Amazon Services Business Solutions Agreement, particularly the liability limitation clause. While the long-term implications are yet to be seen, it is clear that this case may have a profound impact on future arbitration proceedings involving Amazon. As always, sellers are advised to consult with a qualified legal professional when navigating these complex issues.  Here at Amazon Sellers Attorney, we have qualified lawyers who offer free consultation on arbitrations against Amazon and other ecommerce and Internet sites.  Feel free to call us today or submit your case for a free evaluation.

Comments are closed.

    Archives

    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    August 2022
    June 2022
    January 2022
    October 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    July 2019

    RSS Feed

CONTACT DETAILS:

Amazon Sellers Attorney, Ltd.
9350 Wilshire Blvd. suite 203
Beverly Hills, CA  90212
US: +1 888 806 2440​
AU: +61 2 7908 2785
FR: +33485880430
UK: +44 20 3608 1613
Asia: +852 5803 6406
نتحدث العربية ​
Türkçe konuşuyoruz
Nous parlons français 🇫🇷
Мы говорим по русски 🇷🇺
Se habla español​ 🇪🇸
我們說中文​ 🇨🇳

SERVICES:

Amazon Appeals
​Inauthentic Item Suspensions
Multiple/ Related Account Suspensions
​Amazon Verification Suspensions
Forged or Manipulated Documentation
Defending Buyer Complaints
Plan to Prevent Suspension
Intellectual Property (IP) Law
Reinstating ASIN
Fraud or Illegal Activity
Hacked Account
Listing Hijackers
DMCA Lawyers
Amazon Arbitration

PAYMENTS:

We accept payments from all major credit cards and also by ACH transfer through Stripe. Our purchase currency is US Dollar (USD). Payments made through our site are secure.  ​
Payment Options
See our reviews on Picture

AS REPORTED IN:

New York Weekly Logo
New York Weekly Logo
Vents Magazine Logo
Vents Magazine Logo
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Copyright © 2023 AMZ Sellers Attorney ® All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy
Photos used under Creative Commons from thedailyenglishshow, Tony Webster, EpicTop10.com, willbuckner, Ben Baligad, osseous, andreboeni, EpicTop10.com, Tony Webster, wuestenigel, Tony Webster
  • Submit a case
  • Amazon Sellers Lawyer Services
    • Amazon Appeals| Reinstate Your Deactivated or Suspended Account >
      • Amazon Seller Appeal for Inauthentic Items
      • Amazon Appeal ODR Suspensions
      • Amazon Related Account Suspension Appeals
      • Appeal Amazon Verification Suspension
      • Amazon Restricted Product Appeals
      • KDP and ACX Termination Appeals
      • Amazon Drop Shipping Policy and Seller Code of Conduct Appeals
      • FBA Reimbursement and Reimbursement Abuse Suspensions| Appeals
      • Amazon Safety Complaints: How to Handle and Appeal Them
      • Sales Velocity Suspensions on Amazon: Appeal Strategies
      • Win Amazon Sales Rank Manipulation Suspension Appeals | Appeal Package
      • Win Price Gouging/Fair Pricing Suspensions Appeals - Get Reinstated Now
      • Amazon Review Manipulation Suspension Appeals
      • Amazon Variation Listing Policy Violation - Get Help with Our Appeal Package
      • Forged or Manipulated Documentation Suspensions: How to Appeal
      • Amazon Listing (ASIN) Removal? Reinstate Listing with Amazon Sellers Attorney
      • Amazon Seller Fraud or Illegal Activity: Suspension Appeals
      • Merch by Amazon Termination Appeals
      • Walmart Suspension Appeal
      • Ebay Suspension Appeals
      • Twitter Account Suspensions and Reinstatement
      • Amazon Account Hacked? Get Help with Account Suspension Appeals Today
      • How to Open a Second Amazon Seller Account
    • Trademark Registration and Amazon Brand Registry Support
    • How to Settle TRO Claims and Release Amazon Funds
    • Amazon Arbitration for Seller Funds: How to Sue Amazon and Win
    • Amazon Intellectual Property Infringement Complaints - Trademark, Patent, and Copyright Infringement
    • Appeal Closed or Limited PayPal Account
    • Protect Your Amazon Listing -- Hijacker Removal Service
    • DMCA Safe Harbor and Takedown Notices: Protect Your Copyrights
    • Defending Buyer Complaints
  • About
  • Amazon Sellers Lawyer Reviews
  • Amazon Sellers Blog---Latest News for Amazon Sellers
  • Amazon Suspension Prevention Service with Free Appeals
  • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Refund Policy